![]() |

| Sunday League - Regular Season | Sunday League - Playoffs | Weeknight League | Fall League | Weeknight Fall League | Cooperstown I Tourney | Memorial Day Tourney | Labor Day Tourney | Cooperstown II Tourney | |
| 1995 | Yankees (Angels) 17-3 |
X |
X |
Indians 6-2 | X | X | X | X | X |
| 1996 | Yankees (Angels) 17-3 |
X |
X |
Orioles 6-2 | X | X | X | X | X |
| 1997 | Mets 16-2 | Orioles 3-0 |
X |
Mets 4-2 | X | X | X | X | X |
| 1998 | Yankees (Angels) 14-4 | Mets 3-0 | Orioles 8-3 | Mets 7-1 | X | Orioles 5-3 | X | X | X |
| 1999 | Mets 14-2 | Orioles 2-0 | Orioles 8-2 | Orioles 9-0 | X | Orioles 5-3 | X | X | X |
| 2000 | Wood-Orioles
11-4 Metal B-Rockies 14-1 |
White Sox 4-0 | B-Rockies 7-5 | B-Rockies 6-1 | X | PHIL. A's 5-1 | Mets Plus 4-0 | B-Yankees 2-0 | X |
| 2001 | Mets 14-3 | B-Rockies 4-0 | Orioles 11-1 | B-Rockies 7-0 | X | Phillies 7-1 |
X |
B-Yankees 1-0 | Orioles 4-3 |
| 2002 | Diamondbacks 13-4 | B-Rockies 4-1 | Orioles 11-1 | Marlins 8-1 | X | Phillies 7-0 | Fair Lawn Dodgers 4-0 | 2-Way Tie | 3-Way Tie |
| 2003 | Diamondbacks 16-1 | Diamondbacks 4-0 | New Yorkers 12-4 | B-Rockies 7-2 | X | Phillies 7-1 |
X |
Mets Plus 2-0 | Perry's Stars 5-1 |
| 2004 | Diamondbacks 15-2 | Giants 4-1 | RS Indians
13-2 PO Red Sox 2-0 |
B-Yankees 7-2 | X | Orioles 4-0 | 2-Way Tie | Orioles Plus 2-0 | Phillies 6-1 |
| 2005 | Giants 18-0 | Mets 3-0 | RS Indians
12-3 PO Tigers 3-0 |
Marlins 9-0 | X | Buffalo 4-2 |
X |
Orioles Plus 2-0 |
X |
| 2006 | Mets 13-3 | Giants 4-0 | RS Indians 13-1-1 | Black Sox 8-2 | Orioles 7-1 | Orioles 6-1 | Orioles 2-0 | X | X |
| 2007 | Mahwah Dodgers 13-3 | Giants 4-1 |
RS Indians 11-3-2 PO Orioles & Indians |
Phillies 8-2 | Orioles 8-1 | Nashville 6-2 | Oriole/Braves 2-0 | X | X |